Jim Aparo does the cover again, for Detective 441 (June/July 1974), but the Archie Goodwin Batman story inside has art by Howard Chaykin.
This story also features the debut of Harvey Bullock, a Gotham police lieutenant who is not impressed with Batman or his methods at all. His role is quite small, just at the top of the story, the set-up that leads Batman to the house where he faces Robin’s kidnapper. Bullock would not appear again for almost 10 years, but eventually become a solid supporting cast member for Batman.
The bulk of the story has Batman in a trap-filled house, facing a self-appointed judge who has passed sentence on Batman, blaming him for his daughter’s blindness as the result of a mugging, which he failed to prevent.
The daughter does not blame Batman, and tries to stop her father. Unwittingly, she succeeds when her blindness leads her in to one of the traps, which kills her. Heart-broken, her father gives up to Batman.
This issue contains absolutely the best chapter of Goodwin and Simonson’s Manhunter saga, taking place entirely within a crumbling church in Istanbul. Every person I know who loves this series, picks this chapter as the high point.
Using information from Damon, Paul Kirk and Christine St. Clair come to Istanbul to infiltrate a gathering of the Council, but what makes this tale great is the American tourist family, exploring the same church at the same time, completely oblivious to the other plot.
We see that all is not well with the outer members of the Council, who find there always seem to be reasons to keep them out of the precious inner circle. Christine St. Clair’s father is also introduced, a high ranking member of the outer circle, encouraged to stop his daughter’s investigations.
Of the tourist family, only the boy sees the battle that occurs between Manhunter and his clones.
The story has such a great ending, as the boy saves Paul with his toy gun, and his clueless parents drag him away, complaining that all churches are the same.